Montgomery County Standing Order in Divorce and Suits Affecting the Parent/Child Relationship (SAPCRs)

All of the courts of Montgomery County have approved a Standing Order regarding children, pets, property and conduct of the parties that will apply in all divorce cases and in most SAPCRs. The order became effective March 15, 2009, and will likely eliminate the need for attorneys to request temporary restraining orders in Montgomery County in the future.


To obtain a copy of the Standing Order, please utilize the following link to the Montgomery County website: http://www.co.montgomery.tx.us/dcourts/standingorder.pdf

Supervised Visitation -- What Could go Wrong?

When courts order that a parent(s) have supervised visits with a child, it is usually for good reason. Depending on the circumstances, the court may permit (or the parties may agree with the court’s approval) that visits be supervised by another family member, one of the parents, or a third party agency. 

A recent story from The Houston Chronicle discusses the abduction of a child during a supervised visit arranged by the child’s conservators. The child’s conservators likely presumed that a restaurant like Chuck E. Cheese was a safe place to allow the child interaction with her parents. However, the child’s biological parents took the five year old child during the supervised visit. Thereafter an Amber Alert was issued. 

While the SAFE Program through the Harris County Victim’s Assistance Center is not the most ideal setting to visit with one’s child, it is designed to prevent tragic situations like this one. Whether you are a custodial parent or managing conservator seeking to have visits with a child’s parent(s) supervised, the SAFE Program can assist.   

Texas Legislature convenes today!

Today at Noon the Texas Legislature convened for its 81st Regular Session. Many commentators believe this term will be heavily dominated by homeowner's insurance, gambling/gaming, and economic issues.   Given what the state has been through since the 2007 session and the national economy, there is much to accomplish.

Law makers are likely to introduce several bills pertaining to family law matters. I encourage people to be aware of what’s going on with their government – especially regarding issues that not only hit close to home, but in the home. 

To monitor what your elected officials are up to, stay tuned through www.capitol.state.tx.us/

If you like what you see, don’t like what you see, or have a better suggestion, then contact your state lawmakers. With the advent of the internet, it has never been easier to communicate with these folks and get involved.  Make your voice heard.  

New Orleans parent allegedly kills child to avoid child support

As a family law attorney, I have a thick skin, and not a lot gets to me. The story about Ja'Shawn Powell, however, raises my blood pressure.  I plan to keep an eye on this story through the AP and Houston Chronicle.

Jobless parent wants break on paying child support

In light of the troubled economy, it follows that child support obligors will experience difficulties in staying current on child support obligations. In fact, this was the theme of an article in today’s Houston Chronicle in Lipman’s State your Case column

The parent stated he was one of hundreds of people laid off from his job, and he has been unable to find other employment. As a result, the parent is unable to make any child support payments. The parent asked whether he could get his child support payments lowered or suspended until he finds work. 

Though Lipman’s answer (which was “Maybe”) is a good one, I would go a little farther in my commentary. 

Before a judge grants a motion to reduce an obligor’s child support, he/she must find that it is in the child’s best interest. Think for a minute or two about how you would argue that. It’s tough to say that providing the custodial parent with less money to support the child meets the best interest standard. Additionally, the court will want to know what assets are available to provide for the child, such as savings accounts and/or assets that can be liquidated to provide support. 

The prevailing attitude of many judges is that parents meet obligations to support their children. If that means your child eats before you do, then so be it.   

My comments are not intended to discount the plight of folks having legitimate financial difficulties. I merely suggest that you be elegantly prepared before asking the court, a caseworker at the Texas Office of the Attorney General, or the custodial parent to consider a reduction. Be prepared to show that you cannot pay for your rent/mortgage, car note, and other essential items. Be prepared to show how you’ve tried to gain other employment. Be prepared to show that you are attempting to pay something every week. Something is better than nothing. Be prepared to demonstrate that you are making an effort, and that you are sacrificing to meet child support obligations. 

Democratic sweep ushers change to Houston's 312th Family Court

On November 4, 2008, Democrats won 23 of 27 trial judge positions on the ballot. Though the majority of changes affect the civil and criminal courthouses, the 312th Family District Court will have a new Presiding Judge in January 2009.

Judge David Farr was appointed to the 312th in 2007 after having served as a Family Associate Judge under Judge Judy Warne for many years. Judge Farr has been an asset to the family law center, and his leadership will be missed. 

Robert M. Hinojosa will take the bench in January 2009. If you have business before the 312th District Court and want to learn more about Mr. Hinojosa, view the resume on his web site at http://www.hinojosaforjudge.com/files/Binder1.pdf.

Houston-area children's deaths were a preventable tragedy

During the last week in Houston, two young children died after being left in hot cars by their caretakers. I can only imagine the agonizing guilt one would experience as a result. Busy lives, multi-tasking, and/or a change of routine can lead to accidentally leaving a little one in his/her car seat, but the hot Houston summers are unforgiving.

Area experts advise simple steps to prevent this deadly mistake, including:

  1. Put your purse, briefcase or work ID badge in the back of the car next to the baby seat;
  2. Keep a stuffed animal in the front seat of your car as a reminder that the baby is in the back;
  3. Tape a note to the steering wheel of your vehicle;
  4. Instruct your child’s day care center to call you if your child does not report at his/her regularly scheduled time;
  5. Install an alarm device to the car seat that activates an alarm on your key chain after you are a certain number of feet away from the vehicle. 

Houston's DePelchin Children's Center offers virtual parenting experience for pre-teens

This summer DePelchin Children’s Center is offering a youth pregnancy prevention program for pre-teens called “Baby, Think it Over.” Compared to other states across the country, Texas has a high teen pregnancy rate. Federal statistics indicate that out of every 1,000 teenage girls in Texas between the age of 15 and 19, there are 62 births. Nationally, teenage pregnancy is on the rise for the first time since the 1990’s. 

The program requires participants to care for computerized dolls pre-programmed that cry, have tantrums, need feedings, and diaper changes. Most of the participants reported that taking care of the virtual baby was harder than they anticipated. 

For more information on this program, please visit the article in The Houston Chronicle by Ericka Mellon. 

How is child support determined when the obligor's income fluctuates?

Family courts, in determining a the obligor parent’s child support, look to specific data including the obligor’s most recent pay stubs and two previous year’s tax returns. This data usually provides an accurate indicator of the obligor’s net monthly resources. After the net monthly resources are determined, a multiplier is applied based on the number of children before the court, and if applicable, the number of the obligor’s children who are not before the court (i.e., children from previous marriage). 

While some obligors have a fixed salary, their income may have significant fluctuation, and may be less predictable. Examples include sales reps who work on commission, real estate agents, persons who regularly work overtime, and the self-employed. In those circumstances merely looking at a 2-3 recent pay stubs or recent tax returns (especially if the obligor hasn’t filed a tax return for several years) may not provide an accurate picture of the obligor’s net monthly resources. Under such circumstances, there is case law supporting averaging the obligor’s income for calculation of child support. A recent opinion pending publication by the Texas 14th Court of Appeals supports this approach. 2008 WL 1838023; Swaab v. Swaab, -- S.W.3d -- (Tex. App. – Hou. (14th Dist.), no pet history). There is authority which supports averaging a parent’s income for as long as a ten year period to determine retroactive child support. See In re Sanders, 159 S.W.3d 797, 801 (Tex. App. – Amarillo 2005, no pet.). 

Federal review of CPS includes Harris County cases

Presently about 30,000 Texas children receive services through the Texas Department of Family Protective Services. This agency includes Children’s Protective Services, better known as CPS. Sunday, July 20th’s Houston Chronicle ran a story about the shortcomings of the department based on a review by a federal agency. This federal agency was created by 1997 legislation, and the agency began reviewing all 50 states’ child welfare system outcomes in 2002. Recently there was a review of 65 CPS cases from Harris, Dallas, and El Paso Counties. Though a final report is expected in September 2008, the preliminary data highlights areas needing improvement. 

The article is fairly even-handed in its criticisms of DFPS and recognition of its budget constraints. On a positive note, Texas exceeds federal standards in providing for children’s educations needs. The federal standard is 95%, and Texas scored 97%. 

There were more areas where the state is falling well below the national standards. The most notable was in providing children with permanency and stability in their living arrangements. Texas’ score was 38%. However, providing permanency and stability is often a function of individual and family circumstances, availability of long term foster care, and the capabilities of each family to meet requirements to be reunited with the child(ren). Most of that is beyond CPS’s control. 

Areas where Texas is still falling behind include providing medical, mental health and substances abuse services. These areas can be improved, but that requires lobbying the legislature and intervention by concerned citizens. It is never too early to begin contacting your state representatives about the importance of children’s issues. 

To learn more about DFPS and the review process, visit their web site. To find out how to contact your state representative, visit the State of Texas online.

Custody Battles of the Rich and Famous - Why Should We Care?

Most of the time I roll my eyes when entertainment commentators feel the need to report on celebrity divorces, property disputes, and custody issues since Hollywood is so far removed from the reality of the average person. 

Recently, Christie Brinkley's divorce trial has been receiving lots of media attention.  Since coverage spotlighted the use of a child psychologist in making a custody recommendation to the court, this may be somewhat instructive on the role of experts in custody cases.  For more information on the divorce and custody dispute, visit Newsday.com

Experiences with private child support collection agencies not always rosey

FAQ: Worker's Compensation and Child Support

Question: I receive Worker's Compensation benefits from a job accident I had. Does this amount count in my income for calculating child support?

Answer: Yes, benefits received from worker's compensation is considered as income for the purposes of child support determination. Texas law includes income from all sources to determine a parent's child support obligation. About the only benefits not included are TANF.

Seizure of Children from Yearning for Zion Ranch

Since the Third Court of Appeals in Austin, Texas released its opinion May 22nd the news media has been blasting non-stop.  Rather than limiting your perspective to what the commentators tell you, why not read the opinion for yourself? 

My husband quit his job after I filed for divorce. Can he use this as an excuse to get out of paying child support?

Assuming that you are appointed as the managing conservator with the exclusive right to receive and disburse child support for the benefit of your children, the court will order your husband to pay child support regardless of his employment status. Even if your husband is unemployed, the law presumes a parent can at least work 40 hours per week at minimum wage. The court will likely inquire into why your husband left his job and the timing of that decision. If the court finds that he is intentionally unemployed or underemployed, then the court may determine the child support obligation based on his previous employment. 

Houston Divorce and Geographic Restrictions

Frequently our office receives questions pertaining to geographic restrictions imposed by a final decree of divorce.  Unless the parents agree to another arrangement, the primary conservator of the minor children is restricted by court order in where he/she may live with the children.  Usually, when parties divorce in Houston, the primary parent is limited to Harris county, Texas and the contiguous counties -- meaning the counties that are directly touching Harris County.  This is actually a very broad area as the contiguous counties include Brazoria, Fort Bend, Waller, Montgomery, Liberty, Chambers, and Galveston counties. 

Help for Houston Families Seeking Health Plans

One of the largest challenges for families is locating affordable, quality health insurance.

Recently, Houston Mayor Bill White, launched a web site HoustonHealthChoice.com to assist individuals, families, and small business in locating just that.

When families are in the transitional process of divorce, and children are involved, the family court will require that the parents provide health insurance for the minor children.

I am hopeful that Mayor White's web site will offer a useful tool for families who earn too much to qualify for CHIP but who cannot afford to buy a private policy. For more information on Mayor White's health insurance web site, see the article from The Houston Chronicle from Wednesday, April 30, 2008.

Health care coverage -- not just a national political issue

During the divorce process, many of my clients are concerned about having to obtain their own health insurance if they will no longer be able to have coverage through their spouse’s employer. If your spouse provides health insurance for you, it will be important to find out the terms of the COBRA coverage which may be available to you. However, if you are in the position of having to obtain your own health insurance, a web site sponsored by the Texas Department of Insurance can be helpful in assisting you make consumer health care decisions. For more information call (800) 252-3439, or visit: TexasHealthOptions.com

All of our federal tax refund was intercepted to pay for back child support owed by my spouse. What can I do?

Federal law allows states to collect income tax refund checks from parents who are behind in their child support. If you and your spouse filed a joint federal tax return, and all or part of refund was intercepted to pay for your spouse’s past-due child support, you may be an injured spouse and may be eligible to file an Injured Spouse Claim with the I.R.S. You can make an injured spouse claim if you are not legally obligated to pay the past-due child support, and if you made and reported income and payments, such as federal income tax withheld from your wages or estimated tax payments. During the tax year, if you were a resident of Texas, a community property state, you are eligible to file for an Injured Spouse Claim even if you did not report any income and payments on your tax return. You can make an Injured Spouse Claim by filing IRS Form 8379. For each year that you meet the conditions of an injured spouse, you can file IRS Form 8379 with your joint tax return or amended joint tax return, or you can file it afterwards by itself.

During my ex's visitation period, they won't let me talk to my child. What can I do?

A parent or conservator may petition the court to order reasonable periods of electronic communication during the time when the child is not with that parent or conservator. Effective September 1, 2007, the Texas Legislature added Section 153.015 (“Electronic Communication with Child by Conservator”) to the Texas Family Code, which allows the court discretion to supplement a conservator’s possession and access to a child by ordering contact via telephone, e-mail, instant messaging or webcam. When considering whether to award electronic communication, the court will examine what is in the best interest of the child, whether electronic equipment necessary to facilitate the electronic communication is reasonably available to all parties, and any other factor the court considers appropriate. Section 153.015 of the Texas Family Code applies to a Suit Affecting the Parent-Child Relationship filed before, on, or after September 1, 2007.

How do I communicate with my "ex" when we can't stand each other?

When parents are divorcing it’s not uncommon for communication to become tense. The most common mistake I see people make is to use their children as “messengers” for topics such as child support, unpaid bills, school activities, and when and how pick-up and drop-off will be accomplished. We’ve all heard the phrase “Don’t shoot the messenger!” Think about this and imagine how your child feels. 

If you and your spouse are not yet at the place where you can have a civil conversation, but must still communicate, try using e-mail. That provides you both with a communication tool that can be used at a safe distance without the tension of face-to-face or over the phone awkwardness. However, be nice in those e-mails and assume they could be the next court exhibit. 

If e-mail is still too hot to handle, another option is software found at www.ourfamilywizard.com. This site allows parents to manage children’s issues, school activities, calendars, and expenses. The site offers a tour and a range of plans. If you’re at your wit’s end, this might be a tool that can help you.

Child Support FAQ: Can my spouse's Ex garnish my wages for support?

One question that I am frequently asked is whether or not an ex-husband or ex-wife can "garnish" a new spouse's wages or assets for back child support.  The answer is NO!  If the obligor parent remarries, his/her new spouse is not liable for current or back child support payments.  In fact, the courts cannot consider the wages of a new spouse in calculating child support.

There is, however, one caveat.  If you and your spouse file taxes jointly and you expect an IRS refund check, the Texas Office of the Attorney General is entitled to divert your spouse's portion of the refund to satisfy a child support arrearage.  If you think this might be a problem for you and your spouse, speak to your tax advisor about filing separately. 

Health Insurance - What is "Reasonable Cost?"

When involved in a suit affecting the parent child relationship, Texas law requires that children have health care coverage. Health insurance coverage continues to rise at an alarming rate, so it is important to know what the law considers to be reasonable. 

In September 2007, the Texas legislature amended the family code to define reasonable cost as follows: “…the cost of health insurance coverage for a child that does not exceed 9% of the responsible parent’s annual resources.” Tex. Fam. Code Section 154.181 (e). 

FAQ Regarding Child Support and Visitation

One of the recurring questions I receive from clients deals with child support and visitation, and it goes something like this – “I pay child support but the other parent doesn’t let me see my son/daughter. Do I still have to pay child support?” The answer is always, yes.

While it seems unjust to be denied access to your child despite the fact that you pay child support, that is not a basis to withhold support.  First, visitation and child support are mutually exclusive issues, and second, withholding support only hurts the child. 

If the custodial parent is denying access to the child, you may seek to enforce your existing court orders allowing possession and access to your child, or you may file suit to request possession and access, known as a SAPCR (Suit Affecting the Parent-Child Relationship). 

Remember, it is also unlawful for a custodial parent to deny possession and access based on the other parent owing back child support. 

 

Who's the Daddy? Answers now in a box!

Recently the media went wild with stories about the availability of retail DNA paternity tests from Sorenson Genomicis and Identigene. Like pregnancy tests and cholesterol tests, a DNA tests can now be completed in the privacy of one’s own home. For more information on the product, see http://www.businesswire.com/portal/site/google/index.jsp?ndmViewId=news_view&newsId=20071126005139&newsLang=en

The at home kit costs about $30.00, plus there is an additional lab fee of $119.00 that must be submitted with the samples. However, before you run to a Houston-area drug store, be aware of two important facts. First, the tests are presently sold in only West Coast and Midwestern stores. Second (and most importantly) the results of an at-home DNA tests are most likely inadmissible in court to prove or disprove allegations of parentage. This is due to sample collection procedures and chain of custody issues.

Nevertheless, availability of at-home testing is another modern convenience which allows consumers to obtain parentage answers in the privacy of their own home through non-invasive procedures. 

Medical Savings Plans - One Alternative for Handling Children's Medical Expenses

Many employees have access to pre-tax savings devices called Medical Savings Plans or Medical Savings Accounts. Through such plans, an enrolled employee participant may designate a portion of his/her pre-tax income to be deposited in an account designated for health care. One of the benefits is lowering the employee’s taxable income.  Another benefit is saving for large ticket items such as annual deductibles, surgeries, braces, or other medical services which may not be covered by an insurance carrier.

I used to dislike such plans because withdrawing funds for reimbursement was too burdensome and paper-work intensive for the tax benefit. However, I have heard that many medical savings plans are much more user friendly these days, offering access to the deposited funds through a debit card.  

For older children who take themselves to dental appointments or to the orthodontist, this may be a great vehicle for paying and tracking the child’s medical expenses. 

For more information on such plans, speak to your human resources department or your CPA to learn more about the tax benefits. 

Sample Letter for Medical Expense Notification

Besides just sending the other parent receipts for your child’s medical expenses, you should consider writing a brief cover letter to explain what you are sending. This does not have to be typed or fancy. 

A sample letter could be as follows:

*Date*

VIA USPS First Class Mail

VIA USPS Certified Mail, Return Receipt Requested - *certified mail number*

Dear *Parent*:

Enclosed please find receipts for *child’s* medical expenses for the month of *month and year.* My total out-of-pocket expense was *$*. Your portion (*%*) is *$*. 

Please let me know if you have any questions. 

Regards,

*Your name*

How do I get reimbursed for my child's medical expenses?

One of the many points of contention for divorced parents is the children’s medical expenses. However, with a little advance planning and organization, much of this controversy can be avoided. 

Whether you are the primary custodian or the non-primary custodian, the starting place is your final decree of divorce. Your decree should include a section that spells out the provisions for health care. Within that section should be precise language stating how co-payments, out of network services, and uninsured medical expenses are to be handled between the parents. Your decree may differ, but usually, the parents split the cost of any medical co-payments, prescription drugs, and uninsured medical bills. 

After reviewing your decree to understand the rules, the next step is to keep good records. If you take the child to the doctor, always request a receipt that clearly shows the cost for the office visit or service, the amount of the co-pay remitted (if any), and the amount to be submitted to the insurance carrier. If you are the parent who took the child to the doctor, then keep a copy of your canceled check or credit card statement to show payment was made. 

An area where I see many of my own clients go off track is notification of the other parent. Do not rely on just verbal notification to obtain reimbursement, and above all do not make your children the messenger that one parent owes the other. Also, do not keep a backlog of these bills and/or send them on a sporadic basis. Instead, provide copies of the billing statements, prescription receipts, etc. to the other parent on at least a monthly basis so he/she knows what was provided and how much he/she must pay. If you anticipate difficulty in getting reimbursed for medical expenses, then it is critical to send copies of all documentation via USPS First Class Mail and via USPS Certified Mail, Return Receipt Requested. If the other parent does not pick up certified mail, and if the regular mail was not returned to sender for a bad address, then the presumption is that the parent received the bills. This is very important evidence should you need to file an enforcement action against the other parent.

To reiterate, the keys are:  (1) knowing the rules established in your divorce decree, (2) keeping good records, (3) communicating effectively, and (4) maintaining proof of those communications.    

The Texas Lawyer's Creed - Part I of III

The public’s perception of lawyers has historically been low, and evidence of that can be found by reading Shakespeare’s Henry VI (Part 2). The famous passage reads “The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers…” Modern day drama (both TV and movies) helps to perpetuate the role of the attorney as a less than scrupulous member of society. However, my view is that the individual determines how he/she operates as a professional. In fact, I go over the Texas Lawyer’s Creed with each of my clients before we begin working together. 

The creed is broken into three parts – (1) Lawyer to Client; (2) Lawyer to Lawyer; and, (3) Lawyer to Judge. This post focuses on how the lawyer should interact with his/her client.

                A lawyer owes to a client allegiance, learning, skill, and industry. A lawyer shall employ all appropriate means to protect and advance the client’s legitimate rights, claims, and objectives. A lawyer shall not be deterred by any real or imagined fear of judicial disfavor or public unpopularity, nor be influenced by mere self-interest.

1.       I will advise my client of the contents of this creed when undertaking representation.

2.       I will endeavor to achieve my client’s lawful objectives in legal transactions and in litigation as quickly and economically as possible.

3.       I will be loyal and committed to my client’s lawful objectives, but I will not permit that loyalty and commitment to interfere with my duty to provide objective and independent advice.

4.       I will advise my client that civility and courtesy are expected and are not a sign of weakness.

5.       I will advise my client of proper and expected behavior.

6.       I will treat adverse parties and witnesses with fairness and due consideration. A client has no right to demand that I abuse anyone or indulge in any offensive conduct.

7.       I will advise my client that we will not pursue conduct which is intended primarily to harass or drain the financial resources of the opposing party.

8.       I will advise my client that we will not pursue tactics which are intended primarily for delay.

9.       I will advise my client that we will not pursue any course of action which is without merit.

10.   I will advise my client that I reserve the right to determine whether to grant accommodations to opposing counsel in all matters that do not adversely affect my client’s lawful objectives. A client has no right to instruct me to refuse reasonable requests made by other counsel.

11.   I will advise my client regarding the availability of mediation, arbitration, and other alternative methods of resolving and setting disputes.

The Future of the Harris County Family Law Center

On November 6th, Harris County citizens have the opportunity to vote on many important issues.  One that I wish to bring to your attention is Proposition No. 5, regarding a bond to fund construction of a new family law courthouse. 

Trey Yates, Chair of the Houston Bar Association Family Law Section  wrote an outstanding summary of the issue to the members of the Houston Bar Association, which I include below.  I urge you to vote on November 6th. 

            On November 6, the citizens of this county will have the opportunity to vote on several bond proposals, one of which concerns the funding of a new Harris County Family Law Center. I urge you to support the passage of the Harris County bond issue, Proposition No. 5.

            The approval of this bond will ensure that Harris County families are no longer forced to resolve family law issues in an overcrowded, outdated and unsafe facility. Virtually every person in this city has been or will be affected, directly or indirectly, by a family dispute resolved in our Family Law court system. The current Harris County Family Law building was completed in 1969 and originally housed three family law courts. Today the same building has nine family district courts each with an elected family law Judge, an associate Judge and a court staff; plus four additional courts each containing judges who handle attorney general child support cases plus a court staff. These judges serve approximately 120,000 litigants per year (1 ½ times the number of Harris County civil courthouse filings and 10,000 more cases per year than the criminal courts). A review of various options determined that remodeling the facility would not be cost-effective due to the inefficient design of the current facility.

            Today, attorneys and their clients must discuss complex and confidential case issues in crowded hallways without any privacy, and anyone can access nearly any current or past family case file. Victims of family violence are forced to stand unprotected and in close vicinity to the perpetrators of the violence. In a full courtroom, the victims are seated across a small aisle from their perpetrators, with one bailiff to control a crowded courtroom. Children, while testifying, must face their parents in an adversarial environment.

            A new facility would provide the citizens of this county with an updated, state of the art building which will offer the necessary services under one roof, impossible in the current structure. The new facility would have separate entrances for domestic violence victims; improved security; conference rooms to ensure privacy; immediate testing facilities for drug and alcohol testing; separate rooms to allow video testimony by children in a less intimidating environment; and offices for the Harris County Domestic Relations office which offers free court ordered mediations as well as investigations and preparation of social studies in contested custody matters; along with other support facilities. Although these services are currently available to families, they are in separate facilities, making access difficult and more expensive. The new facility will bring these services under one roof, allowing for an efficient and cost effective utilization of services.                                

            Voting “FOR” the Harris County bond issue Proposition 5 on November 6, 2007 will ensure that the current, outdated and sub-par facility is replaced by a new Harris County Family Law Center which is cost-efficient and safer. As with the other Harris County bond issues, there will be no tax increase associated with this bond issue. I urge your support of Proposition 5.

Sincerely,

Sam M. (Trey) Yates, III

Chair, Houston Bar Association Family Law Section

More Tips for Tidy Child Support Accounting

Recently I learned that it’s standard operating procedure for banks to retain customer account records for only seven years. Some clients have child support obligations that run up to 18 years, so the moral of this story is not to rely on the bank for proof that you paid child support. Be a geek and wear both a belt and suspenders!   

It’s rare to get a bank statement with your actual canceled checks anymore, but most banks at least provide scanned images. Hold onto these records in your safe deposit box or place where you keep important documents until after your final child support payment is made and an account audit shows a zero balance.

Just this month a client who religiously paid child support (directly to his ex-wife rather than the registry), was served with an enforcement action after his child graduated high school. After pouring through years of canceled checks and statements, we ended up proving the majority of the payments were made. But, it put the client in a bad position to scramble for old documents on short notice. 

The other moral to the story is not to make child support payments directly to the custodial parent. 

The Dangers of Cash Child Support Payments

One way clients get off track with child support is by making informal payments to the custodial parent, rather than making payments through the local child support registry, or the Texas State Disbursement Unit (SDU). 

It is hard to say “No” when the custodial parent requests or demands child support money on the spot (often in the presence of the child) to buy him/her a new pair of soccer cleats, a cheerleading uniform, etc. However, to keep yourself on track with the SDU, just say NO – unless you’re okay with never getting credit for the payment.

When the obligor pays cash directly to the custodial parent, there is no method for that payment to be accounted for by the SDU – even if the custodial parent provides you with a receipt. For all practical purposes, it’s as if that payment never occurred. 

Later on, if the custodial parent seeks enforcement of child support through the Office of the Attorney General or through a private attorney, there is no proof the obligor made those cash payments. When I explain this to clients, they feel cheated and upset, often citing the “do right” law. Unfortunately, these clients don’t appreciate the formalities of evidence and the legal system. What is acceptable in the every day world fails to meet legal standards in court, and that’s what counts in child support enforcement actions. 

If the custodial parent needs extra cash for child related expenses that crop up, it’s best to make an extra payment through the local registry or SDU. That way, the parent’s child support account is promptly credited with the money, and there is an official record of the payment. 

Of course, there are times when child related expenses can’t wait. Just beware that if you pay child support outside the SDU, be prepared not to receive any official credit for it in court. 

Child Support - Keeping Your Account Straight

When a family court sets child support, the parties’ and their attorneys are responsible for establishing an account with either the local child support registry or Texas Child Support State Disbursement Unit (SDU) in San Antonio, Texas. A central purpose is to provide a neutral third party to monitor the obligor’s payments and report arrearages to the Office of the Attorney General. While many of my clients groan about paying child support through the SDU (or through wage withholding) rather than directly paying the custodial parent, I remind them that the account eliminates future disputes between the parents, if used properly. 

Child support registries and the SDU are run by humans, and as we know, humans are subject to making mistakes. Whether you are the child support obligor or obligee, I highly encourage you to request an audit of your child support account at least every two years. This is as important as checking the accuracy of your credit report on a regular basis. 

If an error is made in the account, it is far better to clear it up sooner rather than later. Little is as frustrating as pouring over pages of child support history and trying to reconcile obligations, credits, missed payments, and interest charges. 

Another quick check is to review your pay stub deductions. If you are the obligor parent, verify that your employer is deducting the correct amount from each check. If the employer is not deducting enough, it is ultimately the obligor’s responsibility to make sure the proper amount is paid. 

Harris County FOCAS Program and Child Support

In the Houston area the Harris County Child Support Registry, Office of the Attorney General, and Harris County Domestic Relations Office enacted the FOCAS Program.  FOCAS stands for Focus on Collections and Services.  A main objective of the FOCAS program is to monitor the collection of child support obligations from the non-custodial parent and to contact him/her if he/she falls behind in child support payments. 

The FOCAS program's services also include locating the non-custodial parent, enforcing existing child support orders, enforcing medical support orders, and even collecting child support through the interception of IRS tax refunds. 

For more information on FOCAS, visit www.hcdistrictclerk.com/Child_Support/focas.aspx

 

Houston Volunteer Lawyers Program

My office receives at least 5-6 telephone calls or e-mails each week from individuals with serious family law problems who cannot afford to retain an attorney.  I commit myself to taking on at least 3 pro-bono cases each calendar year in the family law and/or probate because I believe attorneys should give back to their community, and for the personal satisfaction I feel in helping someone who would otherwise have gone without legal help.  Many of my colleagues take on pro bono cases, but unfortunately, we cannot assume pro bono cases for everyone who contacts us.

Fortunately, there are other sources of assistance for individuals needing legal assistance.  One such organization is the Houston Volunteer Lawyers Program (HVLP).  HVLP takes cases involving bankruptcy, consumer law, family law, property, tax, wills and probate, and HIV/AIDS issues. 

The HVLP office is located at 712 Main Street, Suite 2700, Houston, TX 77002.  Their phone number is (713) 228-0735. 

How do I get information from the Houston Area Child Support Registry?

Whether you are the party paying child support (the obligor) or the party receiving child support (the obligee), there are times when you will need to obtain information on your account, such as a history of payments, or if there is an amount in arrears. 

To contact the Harris County local child support registry, you may visit the ground floor of Family Law Center located at 1115 Congress, Houston, TX 77002 between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. Monday through Friday, contact them by phone at 713-755-607, or visit the web site at www.hcdistrictclerk.com/FAQ/faq.aspx#CS

I highly recommend visiting the web site before making a trip downtown.  You may be able to take care of your issue(s) on-line.  If you must go to the office, the web site will give you an idea of what information and/or documents you should take with you before going to the Family Law Center. 

The Houston Lawyer Referral Service

"Shopping" for an attorney to represent you in a legal matter can be a daunting task.  The Yellow Pages are chalked full of advertisements, which often leaves the person seeking an attorney at a loss for where to start.  Sometimes, my office receives calls and the caller does not really know what type of legal problem he/she has or what kind of lawyer he/she needs. 

Beyond throwing darts or selection through "Eenie Meenie Minie Moe," try contacting the Houston Lawyer Referral Service for guidance. 

Parenting Coordinators - Commentaries from The Wall Street Journal

Parents interested in learning more about parenting coordinators may wish to review a recent article by Rachel Emma Silverman of The Wall Street Journal entitled A Referee for Mom and Dad. 

The article discusses the scope of a parenting coordinator's responsibilities, as well as how their participation in family cases may be a benefit or a burden. 

To learn more visit:  online.wsj.com/article/SB119016372021831914.html

Be Creative With Parenting Time and "Non-Major" Holidays -- Like Halloween

If you’re a divorced or divorcing parent you know that the Standard Possession Order addresses the “major” holidays such as Thanksgiving, Christmas, and both Mother’s and Father’s Day. However, the Standard Possession Order is blueprint from which parents and their attorneys may build a custom plan for the family. Remember, long after the ink is dried on the divorce orders, you, your child, and ex spouse have to live with the order – so take the time to ask for the things important to you. 

If you have young children and you enjoy watching them dress up for Halloween and participate in carnivals or school activities, ask your attorney to include this in your parenting plan. Parents can either share responsibilities for Halloween, or trade-off Halloween just as divorced parents do with Thanksgiving (i.e., primary conservator to has child for Halloween in even numbered years, while possessory conservator has child in odd numbered years). 

Over the years, many parents have asked me to add special provisions to the Standard Possession Order, such as Halloween, Easter, and special holidays for other religious groups. 

5 Losses Suffered by Children of Divorce

 

A recent post in the Oklahoma Family Law Blog presented by Dan Nunely, deserves consideration by Texas parents going through divorce. 

In her article The Devastation of Divorce, Trish Berg states that children of divorce suffer a myriad of losses when their parents divorce. Ms. Berg points out that it’s difficult to understand the impact divorce has on the children's lives until we examine the losses they suffer in this process. She lists the following five main losses children experience during divorce:

1. Loss of Dad - When parents divorce, typically the dad leaves the home, and may not be present much in the lives of the children. This causes an emotional vacuum for the children, and they may feel rejected, alone, and unloved, no matter how much the single parent loves them.

2. Loss of Money – When dad leaves, so does a lot of the money. Economic resource are, at best, cut in half, at worst, single parent families live in poverty.

3. Loss of Security – Kids of divorce often move to a new, smaller home, in a new town, with a new school. They now have to visit their dad. If mom and dad then begin dating, an entirely new stress is added to their lives. Their sense of stability and security is shaken as their world has forever changed.

4. Loss of Harmony – Many kids whose parents divorce feel caught in the middle. The fighting may have stopped, but now Mom may talk negatively about dad, and dad may gripe about mom, all in front of the kids. Parents may play games with visitation, and hold the children as emotional ransom. This loss of harmony causes tremendous chaos and stress for kids.

5. Loss of Simplicity – Life for children of divorce can get very complicated. They have to schedule everything they do, and remember what weekends they are visiting dad so they don’t play in a soccer league with games then. They have to split heir holiday time - Christmas Eve with dad, Christmas morning with mom. And when life events hit, they have to worry about mom and dad being in the same place. Who will come to my eighth grade graduation? Will they see each other? Will they fight? Family life is now complex and chaotic, and that will last for the rest of their lives.

How to Take Away Recalled Toys

On weekends, I like to write about the lighter side of parenting issues.  While doing some pre-holiday toy research for my 20-month-old nephew, I began to ponder what parents do when their child's favorite toy has been recalled.  I conjured up many nightmare scenarios, but found an excellent set of suggestions through Parenting Magazine. 

If the toy recall drama should affect your household, I hope you find these tips helpful.

www.parenting.com/parenting/article/0,19840,1653070,00.html

University of Houston Law Center - The People's Law School

Each fall the University of Houston Law Center hosts a public workshop called "The People's Law School."  This is an excellent forum wherein the non-lawyer can learn about legal proceedings and procedures that affect him/her on a personal level.  Historically, the most popular classes have been family law and consumer law. 

If you cannot afford an attorney, or if you feel you can handle a family proceeding yourself with a little guidance, then I highly recommend taking advantage of this educational opportunity from one of the country's top law schools.

If you missed this year's presenation, keep this in mind for next fall.  Visit the People's Law School at  www.law.uh.edu/peopleslaw/

Children and Relocation

These days we live in a more mobile society, and issues such as moving and relocation are ever increasing in the family law realm. A helpful article from Kid’s Health was recently posted by the Missouri Family Law Blog, which I post here for your review and consideration.

Sooner or later, many families face the prospect of moving. Disruptive as moving can be for parents, the experience can be even more traumatic for kids, who may not be a part of the decision to move and may not understand it.

Kids may need some time and special attention during the transition. You can take steps to make the entire process less stressful for everyone.

Making the Decision to Move

Many kids thrive on familiarity and routine. So as you consider a move, weigh the benefits of that change against the comfort that established surroundings, school, and social life give your child.

If your family has recently dealt with a major life change, such as divorce or death, you may want to postpone a move, if possible, to give your child time to adjust.

The decision to move may be out of your hands, perhaps due to a job transfer or financial issues. Even if you're not happy about the move, try to maintain a positive attitude about it. During times of transition, a parent's moods and attitudes can greatly affect kids, who may be looking for reassurance.

Discussing the Move With Your Child

No matter what the circumstances, the most important way you can prepare your child is to talk about it early and often.

Try to give your child as much information about the move as soon as possible. Answer questions completely and truthfully, and be receptive to both positive and negative reactions. Even if the move means an improvement in family life, kids don't always understand that and may be focused on the frightening aspects of the change.

Involving kids in the planning as much as possible makes them feel like participants in the house-hunting process or the search for a new school. This can make the change feel less like it's being forced on them.

If you're moving across town, try to take your child to visit the new house (or see it being built) and explore the new neighborhood.

For distant moves, provide as much information as you can about the new home, city, and state (or country). Learn where your child will be able to participate in favorite activities. See if a relative, friend, or even a real estate agent can take pictures of the new house and new school for your child.

Moving With Babies, Toddlers, and Preschoolers

Kids younger than 6 may be the easiest to move, as they have a limited capacity to understand the changes involved. Still, your guidance is crucial.

Here are ways to ease the transition for young kids:

  • Keep explanations clear and simple.
  • Use a story to explain the move, or use toy trucks and furniture to act it out.
  • When you pack your toddler's toys in boxes, make sure to explain that you aren't throwing them away.
  • If your new home is nearby and vacant, go there to visit before the move and take a few toys over each time.
  • Hold off on getting rid of your child's old bedroom furniture, which may provide a sense of comfort in the new house.
  • Avoid making other big changes during the move, like toilet training or advancing a toddler to a bed from a crib. 
  • Arrange for your toddler or preschooler to stay with a babysitter on moving day.
Continue Reading...

Montgomery County Family Outreach Center

Many of my blog topics talk about Houston resources for family law. However, I wish to turn my attention to areas North of Houston in Montgomery County, such as Conroe and Magnolia.   

A good resource for divorcing parents is The Montgomery County Family Outreach Center. The center is located at 812 West Dallas, Suite 150, Conroe, Texas 77301. The center offers the basic parenting class required by Texas family courts, along with other classes such as parenting in blended-families, anger management, and parenting exceptional children. 

For more information on the services available, visit http://resourcesforparents.org/contact.html

How to Tick-Off a Family Law Judge

One of the quickest ways to anger a family law judge is to bring a child into the courtroom without express permission. I’ve seen it happen at the Harris County Family Law Center on several occasions, and the result is always the same. The party who brought the child to court receives a stern “talking-to” from the bench. Though family law often revolves around children and children’s issues, the rule of thumb is to NEVER bring a child to court or into the court room unless expressly instructed to do so by the judge or your attorney. 

There are many good reasons for this. First, children who are school aged should be attending school – not missing school to attend court. Second, divorce and other family matters involve high conflict, which is better left for the adults and not for children to experience at court. Third, court is an intimidating place even for adults. Imagine how a child would feel coming to a strange place where people he/she does not know will make decisions about the most personal parts of the his/her life.  Finally, the subjects discussed in family court are sometimes rated PG-13, R, and at times X! Such topics (and language) are not appropriate for children of any age.

Obviously, there are exceptions to the general rule of thumb, such as when the judge wishes to interview the child in chambers, or during a final hearing in an adoption case. These are times when the judge wants input from the child, and the court staff makes special arrangements to ensure the child will have a good experience in court. 

The Houston-area family law judges are not mean people. They are charged with protecting the best interests of children in family cases, and to carry out this duty, the policies about bringing children to court must be strict. Rely on your attorney to provide direction on this. If you are a pro se litigant, then call the court clerk or coordinator to ask about the court’s policies concerning the presence of children. 

Divorce Planning Tip - Securing Communications

An important question I ask of all clients is whether they have a secure e-mail address and a "safe place" to receive mail from my office.  When spouses are in the beginning phases of the divorce process, accidentally alerting the other spouse to divorce plans can have a negative impact ranging from tipping one's hand early too early or up to and including domestic violence in extreme cases.

If you plan to correspond with your attorney via e-mail, make absolutely sure that your spouse cannot access your e-mail account.  You might consider changing your password or opening a new e-mail account. 

In terms of "snail mail," you might consider renting a PO Box through a United States Post Office location or a private company such as the UPS Store, or Mailboxes, etc.  This is an inexpensive way to make sure your confidential communications with your attorney are not compromised.

Case Law Development: Maine Supreme Court rules Lesbian Couple may Adopt

Last week, the Family Law Prof Blog posted an interesting update on the status of same sex couple adoption in Maine.  I pass this on for those interested in the topic.

The Maine Supreme Judicial Court ruled unanimously today that state law does not preclude unmarried couples from jointly petitioning to adopt a child.  The case involved a lesbian couple who had petitioned to adopt a 10-year-old girl and her 6-year-old brother, for whom the couple had been foster parents since 2001.

The court decided the case solely as a matter of statutory construction, reasoning that if it read the statute to prohibit joint petitions by unmarried persons, the statute would still clearly allow successive petitions by unmarried persons, leading to the same end result.  "With this in mind, construing section 9-301 as prohibiting a joint petition by unmarried persons elevates form over substance to an illogical degree."  In terms of reading the statute to effectuate the purposes of adoption law, the court noted that joint petitions serve the best interests of children in a variety of ways, by insuring continuity of care should one parent die, by enabling access to  broader range of benefits from two parents rather than one, and "Most importantly, a joint adoption affords the adopted children the love, nurturing, and support of not one, but two parents."

Adoption of MA  (Maine Supreme Court August 30, 2007)
Opinion online (last visited August 30, 2007 bgf)

Tags: , ,

Tips for helping your children cope with divorce

This is a worthwhile post recently seen on the Georgia Family Law Blog.


Ruben Francia has an article posted on Your Child - Your Divorce which looks at the best appropriate divorce parenting practices for school-age children. It is well-worth a full read.

Here is his list of some divorce parenting practices that are best for your child:

· Explain what is happening over and over again. Children this age are confused easily. In simple terms, explain where your child will live, with whom, where the departing parent will live, and who will provide care when both parents are unavailable.

· Encourage your child to talk about how he/she feels. Be sensitive to children’s fears. Let your child know that he or she can openly talk to you about the ups and downs of your separation or divorce.

· Read books together about children and divorce. Use books to help your child talk about feelings.

· Answer all questions about the changes, and keep lines of communication open. Make sure your child feels like he or she can ask you questions and get answers about why the divorce happened and what to expect.

· Plan special time together. Set aside special time to spend with your child but be careful not to make promises you may not be able to keep.

· Repeatedly tell children that they are not responsible for the divorce. Children need to be reassured that the breakup wasn’t their fault.

· Reassure children of how their needs will be met and of who will take care of them.

· Reassure children that everything will be ok, just different. Children are invariably frightened and confused by divorce. It’s a threat to their security. Provide extra hugs and kisses and tell your child that you and other adults will always be near to love and protect

· Talk to your child’s day-care provider about the divorce. She will better understand your child’s possible regressive behaviors and will likely offer extra support.

· Talk to your child’s teachers or school counselors about the divorce. They may then better understand possible learning or behavioral problems and will likely offer extra support.

· Keep daily routines intact. Children feel more secure when there is a standard routine. Stick with bedtimes, no matter at which home the children are. Have some consistent chores. Have some time committed to the child, which is treated as sacred.

· Respect, but monitor, your child’s privacy.

· Discourage reconciliation fantasies. Avoid dinners, outings, or holiday celebrations with your ex-spouse; they only fuel your child’s fantasies. Instead, emphasize the finality of divorce

· Be sensitive to children signs of depression and fear. Seek professional help if depression is prolonged or intense.

· Help non-custodial parent stay involve. Let non-custodial parent maintain a regular presence such as a phone call several times each week, messages sent on video or audiotapes.

· Plan a schedule of time for children to spend with their other parent. Be supportive of children’s ongoing relationship with the other parent. Remember that children generally fare best when they have the emotional support and ongoing involvement of both parents.

Parenting and Back-to-School

Now that we're past Labor Day, Houston area students are back in school, which can provide some additional stress for co-parenting in a divorced household.  The Houston Chronicle has introduced a new blog to keep parents in touch with what's going on in area schools.  For more information, visit blogs.chron.com/schoolzone/2007/08/introducing_parents_cheat_shee.html.

Parent Locator Services

The Federal Office of Child Support Enforcement provides an excellent informational web site to assist parents and child conservators locate parents who have failed to meet their child support obligations. With the advent of the information age and data sharing among states and the federal government, tracking down child support evaders has gotten more efficient. For more information, see http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cse/newhire/  

Texas Public Policy and Child Conservatorship

In Texas public policy dictates that children should have frequent and continuing contact with parents who have shown the ability to act in the best interest of the child and provide a safe, stable and non-violent environment for the child. Further, it is the policy of this state to encourage parents to share in the rights and duties of raising their children – even after the parents have separated or dissolved their marriage. 

Joint Managing Conservatorship - What is It?

Section 101.016 of the Texas Family Code defines “Joint Managing Conservatorship” as the sharing of the rights and duties of a parent by two parties, ordinarily parents, even if the exclusive right to make certain decisions may be awarded to one party.

Under Texas law it is presumed that the best interests of a child is served if the parents are appointed Joint Managing Conservators (JMCs) so long as doing so would not significantly impair the child’s physical health or emotional well-being. For instance, if a court finds that one of the spouses has a history of domestic violence, then the JMC presumption would be rebutted.

Even though Texas courts generally award joint managing conservatorship, one parent over the other is usually given the primary right to designate the child’s residence based on a geographic restriction, such as Harris County and the surrounding contiguous counties. 

Child Support Arrearages and Passports -- Another Collection Tool

Due to new rules requring persons traveling from the US to Mexico, Canada, the Caribbean and South America to have a passport, child support registries across the country have seen an uptick in collections.  According to a recent article published in the New York Times, the US State Department will deny a passport to a parent who owes $2,500 or more in unpaid child support.  When a child support obligor needs to travel for business or pleasure, it's amazing how quickly the obligor can come up with the money.  For more information, see the New York Times article at http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/us/AP-Passports-Child-Support.html?ex=1187841600&en=34cd324319326e6a&ei=5070&emc=eta1

Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA) and Family Law

With the war in Iraq and the diversity of the US armed forces, many parents have gone off to combat zones, which creates complexities in parenting for mothers and fathers alike. In 2003 Congress adopted the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SRCRA), replacing the Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Civil Relief Act of 1940. 

The SRCRA limits a court’s jurisdiction to grant a default judgment, offers remedies for the servicemember when he/she is confronted with a suit or judgment, and may impose a stay on legal proceedings while the servicemember is on active duty.  

To learn more about protections under the SRCRA, visit http://www.uscg.mil/legal/la/topics/sscra/about_the_sscra.htm

Child Support Guidlines for the 50 States

To compare child support obligations in all 50 states, Guam and Canada, visit the following web site:  http://www.supportguidelines.com/main.html

Courtroom Behavior

Family law cases by nature are emotionally charged, and as a result, the parties are emotional. Despite the overwhelming urge a party may have for vindication, revenge or proving every point, there are basic rules of behavior that the parties must observe while in the court room. 

The parties should not:

  • speak while court is in session unless questioned by his/her attorney, opposing counsel, or the judge; and,
  • engage in arguments with the opposing party, opposing counsel, or the court inside the courtroom. 

The parties should:

  • control his/her facial expressions and body language in court;
  • dress professionally while attending court;
  • answer only the question asked and not include any other information not responsive to the question; and,   
  • stop talking when an objection is raised.

It is crucial for the parties to demonstrate restraint and good judgment in court. Rolling the eyes, putting hands on hips, heavy sighs, or other mannerisms do not go unnoticed by the judge or jurors. 

The Attorney/Client Relationship

Establishing a positive working relationship with your attorney is very important in all cases, but especially so in family law where the stakes are high and personal. Most clients hire an attorney because they do not have the legal expertise necessary to represent their interests. Though the client has the final call as to the objectives of representation, whether the case settles, and whether the case goes to trial, it is the attorney who determines the methods for achieving the client’s stated objectives.

For example, the attorney has the final say on what evidence is introduced (or not introduced), the legal arguments to make, trial tactics, what witnesses to call, and the examination of witnesses. 

Powers and Duties of the Attorney Ad Litem

After the ad litem is appointed by the court, he/she is required by statute to: (1) interview the child in a developmentally appropriate manner if the child is four years old or older; (2) interview each person who has significant knowledge of the child’s history and condition; (3) investigate the facts of the case to the extent the attorney ad litem deems appropriate; (4) obtain and review copies of relevant records pertaining to the child; (5) participate in the litigation as the other attorneys do; (6) take any action consistent with the child’s interests that considers necessary to expedite the proceedings; and, (7) encourage settlement and the use of dispute resolution. 

Additional duties of the ad litem include eliciting the child’s goals of representation, advising the child, provide guidance to the child, and represent the child’s expressed objectives if the ad litem determines that the child is competent. 

What is an ad litem attorney?

In divorce cases where the parents cannot come to an agreement over custody issues, the court often appoints an attorney to represent the child. When parents are in turmoil, sometimes they are unable to put aside personal differences.  The court appoints an ad litem to provide legal services to the child, and the ad litem has the duties of undivided loyalty, confidentiality, and competent representation. 

An ad litem attorney usually charges the same or similar hourly rates as the attorney for each parent. When the court must appoint an ad litem, the parties are required to pay the costs for this representation. In the Houston area, the cost for this attorney could be anywhere from $1,500 to $5,000 depending on the complexity of the custody case. In very limited circumstances, ad litem attorneys are available through volunteer organizations. 

Courtroom Fashion - What NOT to Wear

I spend many work days at the Harris County Family Law Center in Houston, Texas. Even though few things shock me, I am continually irritated by what litigants and even some attorneys wear to court! A court of law, along with the judge, jurors, court personnel, attorneys, and other litigants, are entitled to respect; part of showing respect for the court is dressing appropriately. This does not mean a person has to be rich or spend lots of money. My grandmother always told me “As long as you’re clean and dressed in your Sunday best, you should never be ashamed to go anywhere.” This common sense approach will go a long way to making a good presentation to the court.  

What one wears makes a statement about who he/she is. Remember that a judge and/or jury will make very important decisions about the life of a family law litigant. One can never go wrong wearing professional business attire such as a suit. If a suit is not in the wardrobe, then consider a collared shirt, slacks, skirt, or nice dress. Things one should NEVER wear to court include, but are not limited to: jeans, mini skirts, shorts, tube tops, halter tops, t-shirts, sweat pants, hats, and flip flops. 

A wise attorney once told me that criminals have a constitutional right to wear nice clothes to court, so shouldn’t civil clients do the same!   

Provisions for Child Support in the Event Obligor Parent Dies

The legislature approved a new section to the Texas Family Code (Section 154.016) and Governor Perry signed it into law on June 15, 2007. This new section of the code takes effect September 1, 2007.

The new section authorizes a family court to order a child support obligor to obtain and maintain life insurance to satisfy the unpaid child support obligation owing for the child’s benefit in the event the obligor dies. 

Note that the statutory language states that the court may order the obligor to do this – not that the court shall order the obligor to do this. I will be interested to see how Texas courts apply this new section and if there will be a socio-economic demographic less impacted by this addition.

Legislative Update: Child Support and Death of the Obligor

An old adage says that only two things are certain in life – death and taxes. If you’re required to pay child support under a Texas court order, you’d better make those three things – death, taxes, and child support.

The legislature created a new section to the Texas Family Code – Section 154.015, which becomes effective September 1, 2007. If the parent obligated to pay child support dies before his/her child support obligation terminates, the remaining obligation becomes accelerated and the unpaid child support becomes a claim against the estate. 

Though most conscientious parents want to ensure the stability of the children’s future in the event of their death, it will be interesting to see how the application of this new family code section plays out in both family court and probate court. 

Legislative Update: Texas Child Support - Being Dead is No Excuse

The 80th legislative session yielded over 300 changes to the Texas Family Code. Among the many changes which take effect September 1, 2007, this entry deals with when the statutory duty to support one’s child(ren) terminates.

Generally speaking, the child support obligation terminates upon the marriage of the child, the removal of the child’s disabilities for general purposes, the death of the child, the death of the parent obligated to pay support, or if the child is over the age of 18 and is not attending or enrolled in high school. There were two substantive changes to Tex. Family Code Section 154.006. The first change eliminates a termination event, and the second creates a new basis for termination. 

First, as of September 1, 2007, the death of the obligor is no longer an event terminating the duty to pay child support. The obligation to remit unpaid child support, as well as future child support, becomes a debt of the obligor’s estate. Prior to the update, savvy practitioners included language in final orders requiring the obligor parent to obtain sufficient life insurance to cover child support in the event of his/her death; however, this is now addressed by statute. 

Second, once the obligor’s child enlists in the armed forces of the United States, the child support obligation terminates on the date the child begins active service. 

Child Support and the Role of the Texas Attorney General

One of the most frequent inquiries my firm receives come from parents in dire need of child support and medical support, but who cannot afford the services of an attorney. Though my firm takes on a certain number of pro-bono cases each year, unfortunately, we cannot accommodate every request. 

Many parents who contact us do not realize that they may seek the assistance of the Texas Attorney General in collecting child support from the non-custodial parent. To seek services through the Texas Attorney General one may call 1-800-252-8014 or visit the web site at http://www.oag.state.tx.us/cs/parents/apply_services.shtml.  

Revisions to Texas Child Support Statute

During the 80th Legislative Session, there were some 375 updates to the Texas Family Code. One of the most important revisions impacts the calculation of child support. 

Current statue requires the obligor parent to pay a percentage of his/her net monthly resources for the support of the child(ren). Presently that amount is capped at the first $6,000.00 of the obligor parent’s net resources. Beginning September 1, 2007, the new cap amount will be $7,500.00. 

For example, the maximum child support for two children is presently $1,500.00 per month, but that maximum amount increases to $1,875.00 per month on September 1, 2007. 

The Texas legislature also provided that this amount is to be adjusted for inflation every 6 years. 

What is a Parenting Coordinator?

In some divorce cases, even after the divorce decree is signed, high levels of conflict and animosity remain between the parents. These are the parties who cannot seem to stay off the court’s docket and continue to seek official intervention for all kinds of matters even after the case is closed. Unfortunately, legal pleadings, motions and hearings will do nothing to solve the underlying problems. 

Where such circumstances exist, the court on its own motion, or on the motion of one the parties may, appoint a parenting coordinator. The parenting coordinator is an individual who serves as a non-judicial referee between the parties and acts as a third party neutral. This concept is similar to mediation. He/She will meet with each parent individually and the children (if age appropriate) before attempting to work with the parties to fashion a solution. 

A parenting coordinator is usually trained in family dynamics, mental health, children’s issues, adolescent issues, and communications. The coordinator’s job is to assist the parties come to an agreement.   A parenting coordinator’s recommendations are not final or binding until both parties and the court accept the agreement. The costs for a parenting coordinator ranges based on the individual’s education and level of experience, but it is certainly less expensive than an endless barrage of motions and attorney’s fees.

Keeping Family Time Straight -- Even When Families Are Split

Juggling home, work, and children’s school and outside activities can be challenging even for the nuclear family, but trying to manage as a divorced family imposes even more difficulties – especially in terms of communications where relationships are strained.

Keeping a family calendar is an excellent way to keep organized. The same tool can be even more beneficial for families in transition. 

On-line resources may provide assistance to keep everything straight. 

www.sharekids.com

www.calendar.yahoo.com

Drug Testing and Family Law Cases

In cases where custody is at issues, it is not uncommong for allegations of substance abuse to arise whether legitimate or not.  In most instances, the family court will order both parents to submit urine, blood, and/or hair samples for analysis by a professional lab.  It is not unusual for the lab to take specimens from parents at the courthouse shortly after the judge's order.

Hair tests are very accurate and each 1.5 inches of hair will reveal history of drug and substance use from the previous 90 days.  While some parties think they can beat the system by getting a hair cut or shaving their head, the lab will get a hair specimen.  It's best not to play games as the court will likely draw negative inferences from parties who attempt evasive behaviors. 

Divorce Support - Where Can I Get Help?

There are numerous facilities in and around the Houston area for parents going through the divorce process.  Most experts agree that it is not the divorce itself that affects children nearly as much as how the parents interact during and after the process. 

The Harris County, Texas local rules require that parents take a 4 hour parenting class prior to final orders.  The goal of such courses is to get parents to see the impact of divorce through the eyes of their child. 

There are many resources in the Houston area, but two excellent centers are:

Escape Family Resource Center

DePelchin Chidlren's Center

Child Custody Issues -- What is a Social Study?

In family law cases where custody of a minor child is disputed, the family court may order a social study investigation. The objective of the investigation is to assesss the needs of the child as well as each parent's ability to meet those needs.

Investigators collection information from actual home visits, interviews with the parents, interviews with the child (when age appropriate), interviews with third party witnesses, school records, medical records, county agency records, and other sources to determine what is in the child's best interest.

A written report is filed with the family court in approximately 60 to 90 days after assignment. The report includes the investigator's recommendation as to which parent may provide the most nurturing, stable environment. The recommendation of the Investigator will be taken into consideration by the court when making a decision in the case.

Can I get a history of my Texas child support payments?

Child support payments are a matter of public record.  To obtain a report summarizing child support payments in a Harris County case, you may use one of the following methods:

By Mail

Send a self-addressed stamped envelope to :
Harris County Child Support
1115 Congress, Room 10
Houston, TX 77002-1927

A cause number must be included with the request.

In Person

You can request one in person at 1115 Congress, Room 10. You can pick up a payment history printout Monday through Friday between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. at the inquiry window.

Internet site -- apps.jims.hctx.net/childsupport/

 

Where do I mail Texas child support payments?

If you are the obligor (the party ordered to pay child support), it is very important that you send your payments to the correct place on a timely basis.  Whether you send payment in the form of a check or money order, it is crucial that you include the cause number and/or account number.  Failing to provide that information may result in a delay of your payment being posted, or it may result in the payment being sent back to you for more information. 

Mail payments to:

Texas State Disbursement Unit
PO Box 659791
San Antonio, Texas 78265

Child Support and the Texas Debit Card

Parents with minor children who rely on timely payment of child support have another option besides waiting on a check from the Texas State Disbursement Unit.  Parents receiving child support have the option of receiving payments electronically deposited into a debit card account.  For more information on how to qualify for this service, please visit this web site:  www.hcdistrictclerk.com/child_support/Texas_Debit_Card.aspx

 

Harris County Family Law Center Courthouse Location in Houston, Texas

Many Houstonians are not familiar with the location of the Harris County Family Law Center Courthouse in Houston, Texas. The courthouse is located downtown. It is not very far from the jury assembly room where many of you have been called to serve jury duty. The address for the Harris County Family Law Center is:
Harris County Family Law Center
1115 Congress Street
Houston, Texas 77002

Here a picture of the building which will help you recognize the structure.

Harris County Family Law Center Picture

Here is a google maps link to the location of the building: Google Maps Link

Unaccompanied Minors - What Parents Should Know

Now that school is out for the summer, airports around the nation see a sharp rise in the number of children traveling alone to visit the non-custodial parent.  It is important for both parents to be aware of the airline's rules and regulations regarding unaccompanied minors -- or UM's as the airline personnel call them.  Though common sense should dictate how children traveling alone are handled, each airline's policies will be a little different.  Since September 11, 2001, airline travel rules have changed dramatically, and the same holds true for youngsters traveling alone.

Many airlines will not allow children under the age of 5 to fly alone.  Others do not permit children between certain ages to travel on flights that have stops, layovers, or that require equipment or crew changes. 

We all want to get the best travel deal available, but when booking a flight on-line, over the phone, or through a travel agent, be sure to mention that your child will be traveling alone and the age of the child.  Additionally, if your child has any special needs (medical or physical) it will be important to talk to the airline about this.

Additionally, there will be forms to fill out before the child is permitted to board the flight.  The airlines are pretty good about publishing policies and procedures for UM's on their web sites.  There is also a web site devoted specifically to unaccompanied minors, which can be found at unaccompaniedminor.net/.  This site has links to all the major airline web sites and UM's.

Have happy and safe travels.

 

Supervised Visitation and the Harris County SAFE Program

Sometimes in child custody cases, the court may order one parent’s periods of possession and access to be supervised. A judge may order supervised visits if there is a history of family violence, child neglect, child abuse, if a parent has an active substance abuse problem, or other compelling reasons found by the court.

In some instances, the court may order the visitations occur at a facility such as the SAFE Program through the Harris County Victim’s Assistance Center.

While the parent ordered to have supervised visits through SAFE may feel shame, resentment or anger, it is important that he/she honor the court’s order and establish a positive history. 

Some advantages to consider about visiting your child through a program such as SAFE are that you will not have to interact with the other parent at all, which eliminates a great deal of hostility and anxiety. Drop off and pick up is facilitated by staff members. The time spent at the SAFE program is an opportunity for the child and parent to have fun together by talking, playing games, or participating in group activities. Unlike the custodial parent, the parent visiting through SAFE doesn’t have to hound the child to complete his/her homework assignments, do chores, or other mundane tasks associated with parenthood. Finally, supervised visitation through the SAFE program provides a venue for you to interact with your child where you may establish good history which will be reported to the court by un-bias third parties. The staff members who facilitate the program note how the visits are going and if the parent shows up. This history may provide future evidence to the court that supervised visits are no longer necessary. 

My child refuses to visit the other parent. Can I be held in contempt of court?

The answer may depend upon which Texas court has jurisdiction over the case. The 14th Court of Appeals in Houston, Texas and the Amarillo Court of Appeals have differing view points. 

If your case is in the Houston area, there is a tougher standard the custodial parent must satisfy to avoid being held in contempt (i.e., serving jail time for violating of a court order).

A 1995 Houston case requires that the custodial parent “drag the kids to the visiting parent’s car kicking and screaming” or face contempt. See Ex Parte Rosser, 899 S.W.2d 382 (Tex. App. – Houston [14th Dist.] 1995, no writ). The only exception is if the custodial parent can affirmatively demonstrate his/her inability to compel the child to visit with the parent is involuntary. 

Other appellate courts have held that so long as the custodial parent has the children ready to go for visitation and they refuse, the custodial parent cannot be held in contempt. See Ex Parte Morgan, 886 S.W.2d 829 (Tex. App. – Amarillo 1994, no writ). 

In the realm of visitation drama, there may be instances where a parent: (1) actively discourages or impedes the visitation; (2) is passive about insisting that the child visit the other parent; or, (3) is truly unable to make a child comply with the visitation schedule. If your situation falls into the 1st category, you run a high risk of behind held in contempt of court. If your situation falls into the 2nd category, you might rethink your approach. Unless you have legitimately exercised every age-appropriate, reasonable option, the non-custodial parent may prevail in a contempt action. That may mean jail time for the parent who does not make concerted efforts insisting that the child visit the other parent, in addition to other penalties such as court costs and attorney’s fees. 

Of course, parents should exercise some common sense. It is quite different when a 9 or 10 year old digs in his/her heels about visitation. In that case, if there is no legitimate concern as to fitness of the other parent, some discipline is in order. The situation is quite different when a 16 year-old with a busy school and activity schedule decides for him/herself that he/she doesn’t want to spend time with the other parent. 

Best Interest of the Child

For Texas parents entering the realm of divorce and custody litigation, the phrase "best interest of the child" will be heard throughout the process.  This is probably the most often quoted phrase in the Texas Family Code.  The best interest of the child shall always be the primary consideration of the court in determining the issues of conservatorship and possession of an access to the child.  See Tex. Fam. Code Section 153.002. 

What does "best interest of the child" really mean, and how are those interests determined?  This seems to be a very subjective standard that could vary from judge to judge.  While that is partially true, case law provides guidance. 

Continue Reading...